Log In | Become a Member | Contact Us

Market Intelligence for Printing and Publishing

Connect on Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn

Featured:     European Coverage     Production Inkjet Analysis

Peter Schaefer from New Direction Partners talks about the types of M&A Trends

Published on February 22, 2011

Peter Schaefer a partner of New Direction Partners explains the different types of mergers and acquisition trends, the differences between them and what they mean to printers.

Cary Sherburne:  Hi, I’m Cary Sherburne, Senior Editor at WhatTheyThink.com, and I’m here with Peter Schaefer who is a Senior Partner in New Direction Partners.  Welcome. 

Peter Schaefer:  Thank you Cary. 

Cary:  You know, you guys have got your mitts in a few M&A deals in the marketplace, in the printing marketplace, maybe you could talk to me about some of the different kinds of deals that you are seeing happening today because they’re not all the same, right? 

Peter:  They’re very different; in fact for the first time in the past several years, we’re seeing three different types of transactions. 

Cary:  Okay. 

Peter:  So the first type is the more traditional type which would be companies being bought for multiples of their arnage[ph], that’s what we saw through the ‘90’s, almost exclusive.  In the past couple of years, we’re for sure still seeing those types of transactions, but we’re also seeing tuck in transactions. 

Cary:  And you could explain that. 

Peter:  Tuck in is a situation in which one competitor is buying the book of business, or the revenues of another competitor and rather than buy all the assets, they will buy some assets, but the primary aspect of the deal is a royalty weight, or a commission weight that’s paid out over time and it’s based on, it’s a percent of the sales that are transitioned over. 

Cary:  Okay. 

Peter:  It’s a great opportunity for the buyer because the buyers in almost all printing companies today have excess capacity, so they can move this book of business into their own plant, fill up some of their capacity and not increase their fixed expenses at all because they have it there. 

Cary:  Okay, great, yeah. 

Peter:  It’s good for the seller because it doesn’t matter if the seller’s making money or losing money, it only matters how it’s gonna look on the buyer’s income statement.  And it’s good for the seller because it beats liquidation.  We should not be seeing any printing companies shut down and liquidate today. 

Cary:  Yeah. 

Peter:  We should see them go into the process of selling their book of business because they will still get the liquidation proceeds but then they’ll also get the commissions on top of it. 

Cary:  And then the third type? 

Peter:  The third type is a variation of a tuck in.  It’s called a cashless merger. 

Cary:  Okay. 

Peter:  And it’s the same type of structure, but there are no royalty payments.  Instead of the royalty payments or the future ongoing commission payments, the seller gets stock in the new company. 

Cary:  Okay.  And so, now just looking at probably the most visible one we’ve had recently would be Quad Graphics and World Color. Does that fit into any of those categories? 

Peter:  Well that would have been a cash – more the traditional cash –

Cary:  Okay, more the traditional kind. 

Peter:  based on the earnings performance.  And certainly you’re still seeing those.  The problem with those transactions is that the public companies is trading at low multiples.  And they can’t afford to pay more than the multiples they are trading at because if they did that, it would be dilutive to their earnings and they would be penalized.  So until their multiples go up, the multiples are going to stay low, so you have low multiples and today, because of the state of the economy and the industry, you have low earnings.  So, low earnings, low multiples translates at a low price. 

Cary:  Ah yeah.  You know, it was interesting to me to see that happen because, you know, Quad Graphics has always been private and for them to go public was kind of a –

Peter:  It was a big deal, wasn’t it? 

Cary:  Yeah, and you know, Joel Quadracci, I have a huge amount of respect for him, and his comment was, you know, we’ve always managed to the standards of public company and we still – because they still own – the family still owns 80% of the company, they are still able to manage generationally as well, which is a tough balancing act. 

Peter:  Sure it is.  I think its going to end up in a great transaction, but you’re going to see a transition.  No question. 

Cary:  Yeah, it’s a very interesting market; you guys must be keeping busy. 

Peter:  We are busy.  It’s been fun. 

Cary:  Thanks for sharing with us. 

Peter:  Thank you, Cary. 

Email Icon Email         


Post a Comment

To post a comment Log In or Become a Member, doing so is simple and free



Recent Videos


Video preview: The Largest Printers in 1992. Where Are They Now?

The Largest Printers in 1992. Where Are They Now?

Published: October 21, 2016

Frank found a list of the largest printers from 1992. It documents the significant changes in the industry through merger, acquisition, and bankruptcy.


Video preview: To Inkjet Or Not? The thINK Conference helps in the decision process

To Inkjet Or Not? The thINK Conference helps in the decision process

Published: October 20, 2016

Jen Mitchell, Marketing Director at Harding Poorman, talks about the value of the thINK conference in terms of staying abreast of industry developments and being able to network with peers. The company has not yet invested in inkjet and views the thINK platform as an excellent part of the education and due diligence process.


Video preview: interlinkONE CEO John Foley Highlights Opportunities in the Association Market

interlinkONE CEO John Foley Highlights Opportunities in the Association Market

Published: October 19, 2016

John Foley, CEO of interlinkONE, talks with Senior Editor Cary Sherburne about the opportunities for printing firms in the association market, helping associations with strategic marketing plans, printed materials, multi-channel and more. "They are starving for this help," he says.


Video preview: thINK

thINK "Beyond the Box" in Production Inkjet

Published: October 18, 2016

Mark DeBoer, Director of Customer Experience at Darwill and thINK conference chair, talks about the maturation of the conversation about production inkjet "beyond the box." He sees more emphasis on data at the thINK conference, as an example, "stretching our imaginations as to what is possible with data." He also touches on the advances that have taken place in finishing for production inkjet.


Video preview: The Past, Present, and Future of thINK and Inkjet Technologies

The Past, Present, and Future of thINK and Inkjet Technologies

Published: October 16, 2016

Bob Radzis, Chief Customer Officer at SG360 and a founding member of the thINK community, discusses this year's conference and how he foresees a bright future ahead.


Video preview: Two Sides Survey Reflects High Levels of Consumer Acceptance Relative to Paper Use

Two Sides Survey Reflects High Levels of Consumer Acceptance Relative to Paper Use

Published: October 14, 2016

Phil Riebel, President of Two Sides North America, shares the results of a global survey designed to understand how consumers value paper. 88% of respondents in the U.S. felt it was acceptable to use trees from well managed forests to make lumber for construction or pulp for paper for printing, reflecting that their primary concern is that the industry does things responsibly. Watch the video for more details, including changes in messaging about paper from Starbucks.


View More Videos


Become a Member

Join the thousands of printing executives who are already part of the WhatTheyThink Community.

Copyright © 2016 WhatTheyThink. All Rights Reserved