Printing Industries Alliance says that printers in New York State don’t have much time to raise their voices against a budget proposal that could cost the state’s printing industry thousands of jobs. That grim prospect stems from a legislative attempt to repeal an exemption from the state’s sales and use tax on printed and mailed promotional materials. Tim Freeman, president of Printing Industries Alliance, says that a budget bill containing a proposal for repeal passed in the New York State Assembly last week. A budget bill now making its way through the Senate does not contain a provision for repeal, but the proposal could be put back in during the negotiations that will reconcile the Assembly and the Senate versions. Freeman says that a budget bill could be finalized before Easter—perhaps as early as next week. That’s why he is urging his members in New York State to contact their senators as soon as possible with an anti-repeal message available here. Repeal of the exemption would be costly. Depending on their counties, printers subject to it would have to collect as much as 10% on the selling price of direct mail, catalogs, and other products and services currently exempted. The negative effect, says Freeman, would be twofold: it would drive printing business from New York to other states, and it would accelerate the trend away from print to electronic forms of marketing. Freeman says that Printing Industries of America (PIA), the Alliance’s parent association, has published an impact assessment which foresees the potential loss of 2,800 to 4,200 printing jobs and $400 to $600 million in annual shipments in New York if the exemption is taken away. Freeman and Vicki Keenan, the Alliance’s vice president for legislative affairs, are circulating the paper in the state’s 62-member Senate in hope of keeping repeal out of the final budget. Because the body’s 30 Republican members probably can be counted on to oppose repeal, says Freeman, the Alliance is concentrating on lining up Democratic senators in favor of shielding printers from the sales and use tax. It is a protection that they have enjoyed for the last 15 years, ever since PIA affiliates then representing New York State succeeded in expanding the scope of the exemption to help level the playing field for printers competing against less heavily taxed print providers from out of state. Freeman notes that the burden of repeal would be felt most painfully by lettershops and by Alliance members who have added mailing as an ancillary service. Freeman doesn’t know which legislators conceived the idea of repealing the exemption. But, he says that a scramble for new sources of revenue by New York State—which faces a 2010-2011 budget deficit of more than $9 billion—is the general reason for its appearance in the Assembly budget bill. Now, making sure that the Senate keeps it out of the final budget has become the paramount concern of the Alliance’s Legislative Action Center. “This is a big issue,” Freeman says.
Discussion
By Tim Freeman on Mar 30, 2010
Pat, Thank you for helping us publicize this problem. Our industry continues to struggle with a very weak economy and this measure is sure to push some over the edge. Ironically, if this sales tax measure is repealed, it will not mean significant revenue to the state. The work will just go elsewhere. We would encourage anyone involved in the printing of mailed promotional materials such as flyers and catalogues to visit our Legislative Action Center at www.pialliance.org and weigh in with the New York State legislature.
By HalH on Mar 31, 2010
If you want to kill the bill, tell the Senate's Democratic campaign committee, the political arm, that all their mailing and printing will be going up 10% this year or next, thanks to the Assembly. Focus on the upstate NY Senators; the downstate ones probably farm all their work out to New Jersey anyway.
By Mitch Schilkraut on Mar 31, 2010
The printing industry in NY is hanging on by its finger nails. This bill will put the few of us that are left out of business. Hay you guys in Albany how about cutting spending and not raising taxes for a change. Speaking of change...beware Dems, Nov. is coming fast so you need to dust off your resumes because from what I hear from "A LOT" of people I speak with in business you will be out of office after the next election. Bye Bye!!!
By John Giblin on Apr 01, 2010
Unfortunately, Hal, the NY State Legislature has its own printing plant that does member mailings, among other things...using political appointees.
By halh on Apr 03, 2010
John, the mud slinging election pieces are not state funded, but paid thru campaign funds to privately owned printing companies.
By Dave on Apr 15, 2010
Just another reason this "State" is repulsive. Vote all, and I mean all of these buggers out. What was it in the 60's? POWER TO THE PEOPLE?