As a lifelong reader and book devotee, I have always had a difficult time imagining myself curling up in a comfy armchair with an e-book. After spending most of my day before a computer screen, it just doesn’t sound appealing at all. For me, part of the enjoyment of the book experience is the feel of the book in my hands, especially those with a high production value (although I must admit I am also an avid reader of ‘trashy novels’ that typically leave ink residue on your fingers!).
Nonetheless, I finally made the leap and purchased Amazon’s Kindle2.
When I first turned on my Kindle, I was amazed at the screen quality. It is about as close to paper as an electronic device can get. Its “screen saver” uses a series of very high quality images (black & white) of classic authors such as Edgar Allen Poe, Mark Twain, Emily Bronte and even a Gutenberg Bible. Books that are loaded on the system are easily accessible from the Kindle’s home page. Although I did peruse the user’s guide, it is very intuitive to operate. Some of the capabilities include reading aloud (choice of male or female voice and variable speed), searching within the book, and connection to resources such as Wikipedia.
I have now read several books on my Kindle and still find it delightful. Although I cannot download books directly to my Kindle from my home (where Kindle’s Whispernet connection is not available), it is simple to purchase books and transfer them to my Kindle via my computer and Internet connection. In another interesting experience, I was walking through the Miami airport and saw a book by an author I sometimes read but don’t always think of, displayed in hardcover for a price of $27.99. After perusing it and deciding I wanted to read it (probably only once), I continued to the gate, turned on my Kindle and purchased it in a matter of seconds for the standard $9.99 Kindle price.
eBook technology is still in its infancy and likely will be very different five years from now. But even as a printed book addict and a proud member of the printing community, I have to admit that I am now officially a Kindle aficionado. For publishers, eBooks are a win/win strategy since the costs associated with producing an eBook are nominal and there is no supply chain waste associated with them. For book printers, however, this marks the beginning of a transition that is only going to accelerate as the world’s population shifts toward a majority of “digital natives” and eBook technology continues to improve. Just like many successful commercial printers are adding marketing services that include production and distribution of electronic materials, book printers should be looking at how they can profitably get on the eBook bandwagon, adding this service for their publisher customers.
For more information about eBooks and ePublishing, check out the WhatTheyThink report, eBooks and ePublishing Primer, available in the WhatTheyThink store. Whether you have a Kindle or not, I would love to hear from you on the subject. What do you think?
Discussion
By Gail NIckel-Kailing on Jul 20, 2009
Cary,
I agree that the Kindle is the perfect vehicle for "trashy novels" - though I prefer to call them "escapist literature..." (After all, I'd like to maintain some shred of dignity!) :-)
While I WILL NOT throw a book away, I've left more than my share in the airplane seat pocket in front of me.
For "read once" books, it's the greatest! For anything I want to have for reference or where I want enjoy the illustrations, the dead tree versions are perfect.
Our home library now consists of more than 3100 volumes - and counting...
By Brian Regan on Jul 20, 2009
I celebrated my birthday this weekend and a very good Israeli friend of mine gave me a hard bound book called "Shalom Friend". Written on the first blank page of the book was a very personal message about friendship and why the book was given to me. I will keep it forever.
By gordo on Jul 21, 2009
Interesting that Amazon was able to remotely delete the paid for novels 1984 and Animal Farm from Kindles. However, buy a book from Borders/Barnes & Noble and they won't/can't automatically delete the physical book from your library at their whim.
By Joe Milici on Jul 21, 2009
Carey,
While we can all find some use for electronic devices, I wonder how practical this will be especially when you have a group of friends who like to circulate their books once finished. Like all technology, at some point the improved digital formats will be incompatible with the device you own and your library of books will be a distant memory or you'll end up buying the printed version which is in line with the publishers ultimate strategy similar to digital music.
By Jim Wilson on Jul 21, 2009
Let's hope that Amazon learned from the debacle this past week, where content was removed from owner's Kindles without their consent or knowledge.
A publisher uploaded several books using Amazon's self-service feature - only they did not have the rights to the manuscripts. To avoid copyright infringement, Amazon not only removed the texts from their site upon discovery, but from the devices of users who purchased them.
The money was refunded to the users for the books, but I doubt any of them will view their Kindle in the same way going forward.
By David Handler on Jul 21, 2009
Cary...I have had the original Kindle for nearly a year, and at the rate of reading three books per month (my average) I've already achieved break-even on my investment. Ease of use is superb, and from what I hear even better on later editions. I have the ability to use Whispernet from home, which makes it quite simple. Two challenges I've encountered: 1) Left the charger in a hotel room, and didn't discover that for a week (as the battery lasts that long)...cost $15 for new one plus express shipping of another $16; and, 2) On three occasions I've fallen asleep reading in bed and the Kindle has abruptly awakened me with a firm knock on my nose!
By Manuela Re on Jul 21, 2009
I agree electronic devices will change the book market scenario and for sure for some applications an e-book device might also be the better choice but we shold not forget about the environmental impact electronic media has. Print is the only 1-time Carbon Footprint media, we should keep this in mind.
By Michael J on Jul 21, 2009
Neat story in today's NYT. Turns out B&N is the game with both feet.
"In an announcement on Monday, Barnes & Noble said that it would offer more than 700,000 books that could be read on a wide range of devices, including Apple’s iPhone, the BlackBerry and various laptop or desktop computers. When Barnes & Noble acquired Fictionwise in March, that online retailer had about 60,000 books in its catalog.
More than 500,000 of the books now offered electronically on BN.com can be downloaded free, through an agreement with Google to provide electronic versions of public domain books that Google has scanned from university libraries. Sony announced a similar deal in March to offer the public domain books on its Reader device. "
http://tinyurl.com/ma2rhb
By Patrick Henry on Jul 21, 2009
Plastic Logic's eReader could give the Kindle a run for its money:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v226DYqlbHQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oaQHDxOxVhs&feature=player_embedded
By Michael Jahn on Jul 21, 2009
I enjoy my Kindle, and while many have been horrified by the recent 'correction' of Amazon by 'undistributing' a two eBooks that they should never had the rights to sell, I am faithful that it is a rare event.
I wrote what I feel about that on my blog;
http://michaelejahn.blogspot.com/
I hope that we standardize on a single eBook files format, hope that it is EPUB and await the day where larger sizes and color devices will be available.
By CJT on Jul 21, 2009
Hmmmm....Amazon takes back books it sold.. lesson learned: digital copy is for license only – you don’t “own” it.
http://www.geekbrief.tv/gbtv-597-amazon-takes-back-kindle-books-it-sold-htc-hero-cinemaview-tv-samsung-hmx-u10
By Heidi on Jul 22, 2009
As a graphic arts teacher this is just another frightening reality of our industry. It is difficult enough to try and keep these kids excited about entering the printing industry when they are being bombarded with all of this electronic technology. Where does it end? What should we be teaching instead to the kid who prefers to run a printing press or folder and not spend the day in front of a computer? I'm guessing packaging???
By Eddie Cianci on Jul 27, 2009
@gordo: While I'm not a supporter of DRM, Amazon claims the copy of "1984" was sold illegally. (They didn't have rights for an electronic version from the publisher.) Following your analogy, that means you wouldn't have been able to walk into a brick-and-mortar book store and purchase it, thus the retailer never could've recalled it.
(Unfortunately this isn't a new issue, it exists wherever DRM is found, including "protected" audio books from companies such as Audible.)
That said, my wife & I were on the waiting list for months leading up the Kindle2 release and now that we each have one, they literally never leave our respective sides. I carry several works of fiction on it at any given time, as well as textbooks / manuals, blog subscriptions, and the latest edition of the Globe.
@brian: While I miss the heft, even the smell, of traditional books, the "kbook" editions do have some improvements over their dead-tree counterparts: members of the same "household" (account) can read the same book at the same time (for no additional cost), I can hightlight & lookup any word in the on-board dictionary (the OED), copy specific passages & make notes (and later search them), instantly read sample chapters (for free), the list goes on.
Sorry, I'm done shilling now! ;) I do have one complaint though, and that is its lack of a backlight...
By Jeffrey Stewart on Aug 02, 2009
Welcome over Cary! I too acquired my Kindle 2 (I know lust for a Kindle DX) as i wanted to see what the fuss was. But I have had a very similar reaction. I love it, but it will never replace books for me. It is a matter of convenience. I have tried novels, but i tend to prefer books in the comfort of my den. But I just read your post via my Kindle out on my porch. I read Print CEO and several other blogs and magazines via Kindle.
I must admit, the back light comments surprise me. I don't think I have any paper books with backlights... do I?
By Cary Sherburne on Aug 02, 2009
Yeah, good point, no backlights on paper! Also, the airlines don't make you turn them off during takeoff and landing ... they haven't figured it out yet, I guess. I read by fiction and non and am loving it. Use the Clip feature to collect notes, and the search feature is really cool. Can't do that with paper books either. Gail said she prefers paper books for reference, but the search feature makes the Kindle a lot more utilitarian, I think. Personal preference! Now reading The Chaos Scenario by Bob Garfield. It was out on Kindle long before paper. Check it out, you will love it. Great book.