Alex Marchetti, President, CEO of Whitestone Marketing Group. I want to share with you a case study that we had with a client that we did some work for at the end of last year. It was Habitat for Humanity and how this all transpired is that Habitat for Humanity who had worked with some printers and some email companies decided that they wanted to apply some direct marketing technologies and tactics to their fundraising campaigns. So they contacted us and said they were interviewing firms and what they wanted to do is they wanted someone who would be able to go in and manage their databases, do some segmentation of their databases allowing them to see what passion points there might be for some of their potential fundraising donors and they wanted to look and see how they could measure the ROI on some of their direct mail campaigns. They wanted to have some fresh, new graphics and some messaging.
So we had several conversations with them and it was a long, arduous process in that they didn’t have a lot of money and what they had to do was make sure that there was a return on the investment that they had. They had not done much mailing in the past year because it didn’t seem to work, but they had come to the conclusion that it was something they had to do. So through several conversations they determined that we were the firm that would be selected to do this. So what happened is we went in and we did an assessment to determine what did their databases look like, what kinds of graphics and campaigns did they run in the past, did they do print, did they do mail, did they do emails, what did their website look like and was it consistent with the other messaging and graphics in the look and feel and we determined from that that when you do an email campaign or you do a direct mail campaign and you drive someone—in their case we were trying to get people to donate—that the expectations of that landing page have to match up with what you had communicated to drive them there and so there were a number of disconnects that occurred within their channel management.
So we created for them a new look, feel, new graphics. We wrote some new messaging. We created some versions. We had three different versions. We broke the database up in three different segments that matched up the different versions of the messages. We created different donation amounts that were based upon historical data and how much people gave in the past giving them an opportunity to add more. So we finished and we did all the graphics. We prepared a direct mail piece, which in their case, they did letters. We did various kinds of letters with tear-offs, BRCs. We also included in there to move them to online donations we added in online channels that allowed them to go in and do this. We then created an email campaign. An email campaign was to reflect the same kinds of graphics, some kinds of look, feel and messaging that we had developed inside of the direct mail pieces. We designed all the emails with the ability, links, donations, things of that sort. We did the code for them. We took the databases and we segmented the databases, created three versions into the email so that they all were consistent in the messaging, consistent in the messaging that went to specific segments.
We then created a calendar whereby each of these were interacting in a consistent, well thought out, managed time for a two month period. So we could say if we were going to do this direct mail piece there would be in a follow-up email which would occur at this period of time, which would support the direct mail campaign.
What resulted from all this is we ran it through the last two months of the year. They had incredible response. I think the email campaign resulted in about a 19 percent open rate. They had never done an email campaign prior to this. They sent us an email at the end of December and told us that it was an extremely strong performance. They were extremely happy with the results of the campaigns and that they look forward to building upon those campaigns in 2011. So we’re pretty excited about it and we expect it to continue to grow.
Discussion
By Paul Schiller on Jan 31, 2012
would love the opportunity to see the campaign. great camera work, but suggest some transitions from Marchetti on camera to show the email, print and online content to demonstrate the concepts !!
By Peter Derby on Jan 31, 2012
I think it stinks you can't view this video without buying a membership. What they think sought me out. i did not seek you folks out. Very deceptive and misleading the way you come across.
By Eric Vessels on Jan 31, 2012
@Paul Great suggestion! We'll look at including this kind of stuff on future case study videos. Thanks!
@Peter I understand your point. We try to make most content free - the majority of our videos are made available to everyone. We also added day passes to allow those who don't want to invest in a yearly premium membership to have access to premium content for five bucks.
We think our premium content value is worth the price of $199/year. You can be the judge though. I've converted your account to a 90 day free trial. Give it a spin.
Thanks for the feedback guys!
By Gina Danner on Jan 31, 2012
I agree with Peter... Seeing the campaign is more important than seeing the individual just talking. While I appreciate the audio story... seeing is believing and creates for a more interesting piece of content. Also more data around what "incredible response" means.
This is what matters in the world of fundraising... Results -- dollars returned on the investment or dollars saved on the innovation.
Paul -- WTT is a great resource for industry insight and resources. It is worth the yearly investment. When you invest in the annual fee you get access beyond the normal PRESS RELEASE library. If you are in the printing business you need to be a member of WTT.
Eric -- very classy in your response to Paul! Good job.
By Paul Schiller on Jan 31, 2012
@Gina - you may be confusing me with Peter. I'm already a member, while Peter is not. And Peter was the one that Eric so eloquently responded to . . . cheers!
By Gina Danner on Jan 31, 2012
Sorry Paul... You are right... I tried to get that right three times... better get back to work!
By Eric Vessels on Feb 01, 2012
FYI for anyone wanting to share this with non-premium members here is a free link to this video (by popular demand):
http://wtturl.com/1s
By Paul Schott on Feb 01, 2012
It would be great to hear from the customer as well. This video was good, but one sided, balancing with infomration directly from the customer drives the point home more.
By Eric Vessels on Feb 01, 2012
@Paul Schott Another great thought! Many times we don't have access to the client when interviewing printers at different events. We will look for opportunities to do this though and try to include that as well as collateral b-roll as Paul Schiller recommended.
Thanks for the feedback!