As I write this, I have just returned from a meeting with the VP of marketing for a direct mail marketing company. The woman I met with had the title of “The Queen Mother of Direct Marketing” on her card so when we met I asked her if I should call her your highness. She laughed and said that was what she preferred. She explained that they have been very aggressive in their marketing activities over the last year and attribute those efforts to their relatively small sales declines of about 10%, during this recession. I told her that while very few companies are reporting no declines, I believe that only the leading companies are experiencing sales declines of 10% or less. Then she joked, “What a novel idea – aggressive marketing to compensate for the sales declines associated with a recession.” I am not sure if she is actually the Queen Mother of Direct Marketing but after hearing this story she is definitely an experienced pro. I met the Queen recently at a DMA event that her company had sponsored. She introduced my presentation entitled, “Increasing Your Marketing Effectiveness with World-Class Variable Data Ad Campaigns.” I am not sure, but I must have done something right because it resulted in a free lunch a week later. Of course, there are no free lunches. This meeting was really to discuss plans for an upcoming customer event in the fall to help her customers better understand and appreciate the synergy that can be created when combining Purls and direct mail marketing. I was thrilled to be asked to be part of this effort and shared what I think are best practices for these customer events which include: presentations by senior staff, invitations to both clients and prospects, marketing the event with at least 3 marketing touches and use the technology (Purls, VDP) to demonstrate your capabilities and the effectiveness of the technology. And, last but not least, you have to make a compelling offer because you have to remember that most Purls are seen as work by the recipients. Therefore, the incentive has to be strong enough to overcome the perception of work. At least that’s what I told the Queen. What would you tell the Queen about the issues associated with Purls? Howard Fenton is a Senior Consultant at NAPL. Howie advises commercial printers, in-plants, and manufacturers on workflow management, operations, digital services, and customer research.
Discussion
By Rebecca Cole on Jun 03, 2010
I completely agree! There are so many things that must be done texactly right to insure a successful outcome. The offer is huge, but also, the data must be good and the design of the piece must be clean so the purl is easily noticeable and there is a clear call to action.
By Thaddeus B Kubis on Jun 07, 2010
I agree with some of the points but one must also measure ROI and if the incentive fits within the ROI model. I work on the formula of RIIM-ROI, Which includes Relevance, Integration, Interaction, Measurement and Return on Investment. Bottom Line, and it always is the Bottom Line, a purl program needs to be one tool in the mix of "touches" that your customer will receive. Data as Rebecca mentions is critical as the clarity of the message.
By Chantal Tode on Jun 10, 2010
Great points. The one thing I keep hearing about PURLs is that they can be a great way to initiate a conversation with a target audience. But that the buck doesn't stop there!
By Marty Thomas on Jun 11, 2010
Another often overlooked benefit of PURLs is having a database of people that visited your website. Even if they don't convert to a customer, you have a very valuable list of prospects that are slightly interested. You can focus future campaigns heavier on these prospects because they will be more likely to convert in the future.
By Chantal Tode on Jun 14, 2010
So true, Marty. Gaining customer data that can be used to inform future campaigns really should be one of the goals of every direct marketing strategy.
By Kel Adkins on Jun 15, 2010
People need to get beyond the pURL first of all ... your base engagement tool is the variable content and very well designed deliverable - be it a mailer, letter, email or insert/transpromo presentation piece ... it’s true that pURLs are nothing w/o the proper offer – but sometimes that offer can be as simple as letting the recipient know that you know how to help them best … the person's name in a URL is what most think of in the pURL interaction and draw - but it's the content and offer of insight (not always a freebie or even a cheesy contest – sometimes it’s just facts that are pertinent and delivered effectively) – biggest asset in messaging: letting the recipient know that spending 3 minutes responding to the deliverable will be of quality and pertinent value to them - personally ... move passed the reference of a personalized URL and look to engagement content (VDP) with a response mechanism that lets the responder know that you know who they are … do this and you will have a win/win on your hands that boasts an amazing ROI – forward momentum in sales revenue and long term commitment from responders
By Howie Fenton on Jun 15, 2010
Wow great feedback. I have to admit that I have been flying around the country the last few weeks taking about Purls, Gurls, QR-codes, sms text and everything short of smoke signals - which can be considered tools to enhance the effectiveness of VDP. Here is my unofficial tally of the effectiveness from the "raise your hands" exercise. Of those people that I ask who is using Purls and who says its effective or not effective: I hear 40% say they can't sell it or its not effective, 40% who say they can sell it and it is effective and 20% say they don't know or have enough information yet. So clearly there are some people getting this to work and some issues that need to be identified and addressed. So I am still looking for answers why some people are struggling with Purls and what can we do to help them.
- Discussion is closed -