WhatTheyThink

Premium Commentary & Analysis

Manage Benefits Costs Through Outsourcing

One of the most significant challenges currently facing printers is the need to attract and retain capable employees.

Thursday, March 01, 2001

One of the most significant challenges currently facing printers is the need to attract and retain capable employees. In order to be successful in today's competitive marketplace, printing companies must constantly improve productivity. And, while new technology, improved equipment, and redesigned workflows all potentially contribute to productivity, most of these tools need the minds and hands of qualified and committed employees to produce their promised benefits.

Finding, hiring and keeping good employees has become a difficult challenge for several reasons. First, the overall U.S. labor market is extremely tight, and there is little promise of relief in the near future. The national unemployment rate stood at 4.0% at the end of 2000, and most economists believe that the unemployment rate will remain in the range of 4.0%-4. 5% throughout 2001. Second, as the use of digital technologies expands to include an ever-increasing portion of the print production process, printing company owners and managers are finding that hiring computer-literate employees becomes as important as hiring craftsmen skilled in the traditional graphic arts. Unfortunately for printing companies, computer-literate employees are needed by virtually all kinds of businesses, and the supply-demand equation now clearly favors the employee.

Finally, printing companies face a real double-edged sword when it comes to employee benefits. It is increasingly necessary to provide an attractive benefits package in order to hire and keep good people. At the same time, employee benefits costs, particularly health insurance costs, are rapidly rising. In a recently released study, William M. Mercer, Incorporated, an international human resources consulting firm, found that U.S. employer-sponsored health benefits costs rose 8.1% in 2000. More significantly, the Mercer study states that the average cost increase expected for 2001 is 11% and that about one in eight employers (mostly smaller companies) expect increases of 20% or more.

For printing companies facing these employment-related challenges, part of the answer may lie in outsourcing human resources functions to a Professional Employer Organization. Professional Employer Organizations, or PEO's, are descendants of the employee leasing companies that first appeared in the 1960's. Today's PEO's become co-employers of their clients' employees, and assume responsibility for human resources administration. Most PEO's provide a wide range of services and benefits packages, including payroll administration, insurance benefits, workers' compensation, unemployment insurance, retirement plans, and assistance in complying with the plethora of employment laws and regulations that now confront employers. For these services, the typical PEO charges an administrative fee that ranges between 2% and 6% of the client's gross wages.

After struggling to gain acceptance in the early 1990's, the PEO industry has become part of the mainstream. According to the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations, there are now more than 2000 PEO's operating nationwide, and recent reports indicate that the industry is growing at more than 25% per year. At least 15 states regulate the industry in some way, and, in 1996, the Institute for Accreditation of Professional Employer Organizations began issuing credentials for firms that meet certain financial standards.

Working with a PEO can provide owners of small and mid-size printing companies with significant financial and operating benefits. First, PEO's can help control the rising costs of employee benefits, while enabling small companies to compete effectively with larger firms in hiring and keeping the best employees. By combining the purchasing power of thousands of employees, PEO's can negotiate more affordable rates on a broad range of employee benefits. This allows many small companies to provide "Fortune 1000" type benefits at a reasonable cost. In a project completed last year, we assisted a printing company client examine the PEO alternative and solicit and evaluate proposals from several potential PEO partners. In this case, the client saved enough in health insurance premiums to almost completely pay the PEO's administrative fee. While this level of savings may not occur in all cases, PEO's can often enable small companies to provide better benefits at lower costs.

A PEO arrangement can also dramatically reduce the administrative burdens associated with operating a printing company. By outsourcing payroll and benefits administration, a printer significantly simplifies the bookkeeping and "office management" tasks he or she must perform, and this may permit administrative personnel to be reassigned to functions that directly contribute to producing revenues. Even more important, working with a PEO enables a printing company owner to focus on managing the core parts of his or her business, without the time-consuming distraction of employment-related administrative tasks.

Given the employment challenges facing printers and the benefits provided by PEO's, outsourcing human resources administration is an alternative that printing company owners should seriously consider. But establishing a relationship with a PEO is a substantial business and legal undertaking. This step should only be taken after a careful analysis of the potential benefits and disadvantages of the PEO alternative, and after the printer has engaged in a thorough process intended to help select the right PEO. Outsourcing HR administration will not be the right move for every printing company, but, for many printers, it can provide a tool for improving performance and enhancing competitive advantage.


Continue reading your article
with a WhatTheyThink membership.

WhatTheyThink Annual Membership

Less than $4/week.

Get unlimited access to in-depth commentary and analysis covering the latest trends, emerging technologies, operational strategies, and key events across every segment of today's printing industry.

Stay informed. Stay competitive. Stay ahead.
WhatTheyThink Day Pass

$5 for 24 hours

Unlimited access to all of WhatTheyThink. Get your Day Pass

Already a member?
Sign In

About David Dodd

G. David Dodd is available for speaking engagements and consulting projects. To get more information contact us here.

G. David Dodd is a principal of Point Balance, LLC ( www.pointbalance.com ), an executive education and management consulting firm. Point Balance provides cutting-edge management education programs designed for printing and publishing executives. The firm also provides management consulting services involving business strategy development, strategic marketing, cost management (including activity-based costing), business process management, and balanced scorecard performance management systems. Dodd is a co-author of Activity-Based Costing for Printers: An Implementation Guide, the authoritative resource relating to the use of activity-based costing by printing and publishing firms. Dodd also co-authored Making Value Added Services Work, a comprehensive reference tool for printing company managers who are just beginning to consider diversification or who have already added new services and are not receiving the benefits they expected.

David Dodd can be reached at [email protected],931-707-5105.

Recent Articles from David Dodd

Product Showcase: The Grey Elephant at LabelExpo

Product Showcase: The Grey Elephant at LabelExpo

In this video, sponsored by The Grey Elephant, founder and owner Askold Zimmermann talks with David Zwang about the company’s solutions for bringing “track and trace” to the printing industry. Read More

Lori Messina on the Importance of User Group Events

Lori Messina on the Importance of User Group Events

WhatTheyThink spoke with Lori Messina EVP and co-owner of Access Direct at thINK. Lori talks about how thINK plays an important role in staying up to date with best practices in the industry. Read More

Interview with Crit Driessen on Canon's Launch of the Océ ProStream

Interview with Crit Driessen on Canon's Launch of the Océ ProStream

Crit Driessen, VP Strategy and Alliances at Canon Océ sat down Senior Editor David Zwang to talk about the launch of the Océ ProStream. The ProStream is a continuous feed production inkjet system targeting the mid-to-high volume commercial printing market. The device leverages Océ technology from its previous continuous feed systems as well as the its sheetfed Océ VarioPrint i300. Read More

Two Ways to Make Your Marketing More Relevant

Read More

Four Reasons a Prospect Should Buy Your Web-to-Print Solution

Read More