WhatTheyThink

Premium Commentary & Analysis

As the Media Mix Evolves, Print Remains Important

Today, digital technologies and applications largely dominate the buzz generated in the worlds of media and marketing. Does that mean that print will fall by the wayside, or is print evolving with the general media mix? Bryan Yeager explores the relevancy and importance of print in a growing world of digital media.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

I recently came across an interesting piece of commentary related to a study that was conducted by Quova, a geolocation data service offered by mobile telecommunications company Neustar. On its blog, Quova stated that it recently conducted a study of 250 marketers to determine the importance of location-based services to those marketers. It also asked about more "traditional" ways that marketers reach their audience, including print directories and direct mail.

While Quova's findings didn't surprise me, it certainly seemed to startle them. This sentence from Quova's blog post on the study results pretty much sums it up: "The good news we learned is that marketers love location. The bad news is they still love paper." Reading further in the blog post, it turns out that 30% of respondents in the study use print directories and direct mail for marketing; in addition, 10% of marketer respondents use billboards.

The reaction by Quova to these findings was a bit frustrating to read, but I feel that it represents the view of many digital-focused businesses offering marketing and media technology today. There seems to be this lingering negative perception related to print in the high-tech industry, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary related to its sustained use and effectiveness. After all, high-tech companies like Apple, Google, and IBM each spend a pile of money on print advertising each year. Would these kings of data measurement and analytics use print if it didn't help them reach their audience?

Let's take a look at some more statistics. InfoTrends' study on cross-media marketing from last year surveyed over 500 marketers from companies of varying sizes, finding the top five media types used for marketing are company Website (89%), direct mail (72%), e-mail (71%), event sponsorship (63%), and trade shows (57%). Looking at small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), we find similar results from an in-depth research initiative InfoTrends conducted at the end of 2009 on this topic.

Figure 1: SMB Marketing Media Mix

Looking at Figure 1, it's not surprising that e-mail is the top media type used by SMBs for marketing due to its self-service nature and relatively low cost. Nevertheless, look at the results below the e-mail category; the next five top selections are print mediums. We're actually revisiting this study on SMBs later this year, and I predict we will see some changes, such as directories moving down the list and wireless/mobile to move up significantly. Just because the media mix is evolving, though, doesn't mean that print is going to disappear anytime soon.

Staying on the topic of SMBs, one only has to point to the continued success of a player like Vistaprint to realize that print is still important. Jennifer Matt further emphasized this point in her last article about the democratizing force the Web has had on SMBs, and I couldn't agree more with her assessment. Look at what else is happening in the market. Online printing service MOO.com recently launched MOO Business Services, a way to manage business cards and other brand identity materials for small businesses. Other e-mail marketing service providers like Vertical Response offer complementary direct mail services. Vertically-targeted marketing automation providers like GuestEngine and Lighthouse 360 also offer print marketing capabilities because their users still leverage it to promote their businesses.

Again, there's no doubt that the media mix is changing, and I'll be the first one to say I love purely digital technologies, as well as the prospect of integrating interactivity with print to improve effectiveness and relevance. I think one of the comments on the ReadWriteWeb post where I originally found Quova's study results says it best. Nick Stamoulis, the president of Boston-based Brick Marketing, stated that "Offline marketing methods are still effective and important. Online marketing shouldn't replace your offline efforts. The two need to work together in order to get the most work done for building your brand." Print still gets the job done; even more so when combined with other media types. As long as it does that, it's still extremely important… sometimes we just need to open peoples' eyes to that reality.


Continue reading your article
with a WhatTheyThink membership.

WhatTheyThink Annual Membership

Less than $4/week.

Get unlimited access to in-depth commentary and analysis covering the latest trends, emerging technologies, operational strategies, and key events across every segment of today's printing industry.

Stay informed. Stay competitive. Stay ahead.
WhatTheyThink Day Pass

$5 for 24 hours

Unlimited access to all of WhatTheyThink. Get your Day Pass

Already a member?
Sign In

About Bryan Yeager

Bryan Yeager is a Senior Consultant for InfoTrends’ Business Development Strategies and Production Workflow Solutions Consulting Services. Bryan covers a number of existing and emerging software and technology markets that enable cross-media marketing communications. He is the author of several in-depth Ultimate Guide reports that span across a variety of software categories, and provides insight through research, analysis, and consulting. He can be contacted via e-mail at [email protected] or via Twitter (@bryanyeager).

Recent Articles from Bryan Yeager

Exploring Mobile Marketing Opportunities Beyond the Barcode

Mobile barcodes are a hot topic in the world of marketing and advertising, and printers have latched onto this technology to add interactivity and value to print media. While barcodes are certainly relevant, there are other mobile marketing services that need to be explored, as they represent a huge untapped opportunity by many service providers. Read More

Top Five Software Trends to Watch at Graph Expo 2011

The theme for Graph Expo 2011 is "Embrace Technology", and software will be a key component of the technology being exhibited at this year's event. Bryan Yeager shares his predictions for the top five software trends to watch for in Chicago next month. Read More

Is Hybrid Workflow Really "Hybrid" Anymore?

With the rise in prominence of digital printing, the concept of “hybrid workflow” emerged as a way for printers to effectively leverage digital within the confines of their existing offset print workflows. Have print businesses caught on to hybrid workflow? Bryan Yeager gives us an update. Read More

Digital Media: Ready for Primetime

While the digital media publishing market is still relatively tiny compared to the traditional print media market, a mix of hardware, software, and services are positioning digital media for significant growth in the next few years. Bryan Yeager highlights some recent research on digital media trends and points out what we can expect to see on the horizon. Read More

Integration: What's It Really All About?

"Integration" is as common of a word in technology as "synergy" is in business. Integration may not mean much to you, but it should because it unlocks opportunities for workflow automation and optimization. Bryan Yeager tells us all about it. Read More